In this book, alan berger further develops the new theory of reference as formulated by kripke and putnam applying it in novel ways to many philosophical problems concerning reference and existence. An empirical investigation concerning the language acquisition of bilingual children frenchgerman. A cataphoric reference unit refers to another unit that is introduced later on in the textspeech. In a narrower sense, anaphora is the use of an expression that depends specifically upon an antecedent expression and thus is contrasted with cataphora, which is the use of an expression that depends upon a postcedent. Reference and anaphoric relations studies in linguistics and.
Anaphora thus has a powerful effect on hammering home an important point. It can be compared with anaphoric reference, which means a word refers back to another word for its meaning. Journal of literacy research effect of anaphoric references and noun phrase organizers on paragraph comprhensionanne stevens. Anaphoric reference means that a word refers back to another word for its meaning, previously mentioned words,cataphoric reference, which means a word in a text refers to another later in the text and you need to look forward to understand, subsequent words. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. A number of classifications of anaphora and referring expressions have been developed 1621.
This study sought to find out what these devices are and paid attention to anaphoric references as a cohesive device. However, it is only effective when a speaker uses it mindfully. Anaphoric reference occurs when a word or phrase refers to. Also known as anticipatory anaphora, forward anaphora, cataphoric reference, or forward reference. The errors committed in this respect show the disability of learners in using anaphoric and cataphoric reference of the definite article, the past. Anaphoric reference means that a word refers back to another word for its meaning, previously mentioned words, cataphoric reference, which means a word in a text refers to another later in the text and you need to look forward to understand, subsequent words. Definition and examples of anaphora in english grammar. Examples of anaphora in the narrow sense and cataphora are given next. The role of the anaphoric referential relations in. We describe three experiments that use priming methodology to investigate the nature of the abstract mental representations activated during pronoun resolution, in order to contribute to our understanding of how structural representations and semantic coherence representations influence pronoun interpretation. She can refer to the lady anaphoric reference or to someone else. Definition and examples of cataphora in english grammar. Mar 08, 2011 hi everyone, ive seen a little bit anaphoric cueing out there and am looking for more teachers or service providers or parents who have used it. A proform is a cataphor when it points to its right toward its postcedent.
Richard nordquist is professor emeritus of rhetoric and english at georgia southern university and the author of several universitylevel grammar and composition textbooks. Eine empirische untersuchung zum spracherwerb bilingualer kinder franzdsischdeutsch the development of the expression of object reference using determiners. In the example in 1, the referent is the actual body organ that is about to be ligated during the operative procedure. Anaphoric and cataphoric references in pragmatics free essays. Cataphoric definition of cataphoric by the free dictionary. Berger argues that his notion of anaphoric background condition and anaphoric links within a linguistic community are crucial not only to a theory of reference, but to the analysis of these problems as well. For example in shakespeares romeo and juliet this is an anaphora. In english grammar, anaphora is the use of a pronoun or other linguistic unit to refer back to another word or phrase. A cohesive device in written and spoken discourse nneka umeraokeke abstract. So any of the examples above of anaphoric and cataphoric reference are also examples of endophoric reference. She shows that syntactic constraints on anaphoric binding can be expressed in terms of just three grammatical concepts.
As anaphoric dependencies involve a variety of factors, and prima facie show substantial crosslinguistic variation, it is often the case that textbooks offer only a partial overview of the phenomena or provide only one theoretical account of a limited set of data. In part i, berger distinguishes between two styles of rigid designation. Three experiments provide evidence that an anaphoric noun phrase reinstates its antecedent in the course of comprehension. Anaphora is an important tool for speechwriters, because its repetition can set a tone, rally a crowd, and focus attention on the points that the speaker wants those listening to focus on. Anaphoric resolution and text comprehension for readers of german victoria c. This volume contains a careful selection of papers concerned with actual research questions on anaphoric reference, a subject of current interest with various linguistic subdisciplines.
Anaphors in text cognitive, formal and applied approaches to anaphoric reference. Referencing there are two referential devices that can create cohesion. The effect of anaphoric references and noun phrase organizers. In english grammar, cataphora is the use of a pronoun or other linguistic unit to refer ahead to another word in a sentence i. Anaphora is an important concept for different reasons and on different levels.
References the handbook of child language wiley online. Typically occurs when a word is followed by another word with a similar meaningfor example, when presenting the word ant before the word bug causes a person to respond faster to the word bug than if ant had not preceded it. An anaphoric reference unit, on the other hand, refers to another unit that was introduced earlier. Ellipsis, anaphoric and cataphoric references text 1 the princess and the pea 1. Anaphoric reference often makes use of the definite article the, because one of the functions of the definite article is to indicate that something has already been mentioned. As a literary device, anaphora serves the purpose of giving artistic effect to passages of prose and poetry. Semantics can be defined as the study of meaning of lexical words and expressions.
If anaphoric references and noun phrase organizers perform a cohesive function, their presence in a paragraph should have some demonstrable psychological effect on the reader. This study revealed that only the noun phrase organizer condition was significant in promoting comprehension and indicated no difference in time scores by paragraph condition. According to, anaphoric pronouns are pronouns that refer to an antecedent pronoun a function word that is used in place of a noun or noun phrase. Ultimately, the function really depends on how its used in the context, but heres a general list of some of the functions that they can serve from the top of my head. Identify whether the reference words are anaphoric or cataphoric. It can be compared with cataphoric reference, which means a word refers to ideas later in the text. Anaphoric reference, cataphoric reference, comprehension. He explains things in a very easy to understand way notice that you have a link to his blog. As with all good writing, each word and sentence should be carefully crafted and constructed with the writers argument and audience in mind. Anaphoric definition of anaphoric by merriamwebster.
He sat down at the table and took a small box from his pocket. The findings are related to previous research on anaphoric reference in first and second language contexts, emphasizing the significance of this factor in measurement of language acquisition. Subjects read a series of texts each containing a target item. Jan 31, 20 ellipsis, anaphoric and cataphoric references text 1 the princess and the pea 1.
The research demonstrated that there are differences in the processing of sentences containing anaphoric pronouns e. More usually, the noun that the pronoun links forward to follows soon after. Berger argues that his notion of anaphoric background condition and anaphoric links within a linguistic community are crucial not only to a. Once upon a time there was a prince who wanted to marry a princess. Dear teachers, the following is the explanation to reference and substitution from wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Errors committed by efl learners in using anaphoric and. Key concepts in elt anaphora oxford academic journals.
Both effects together are called either anaphora broad sense or less ambiguously, along with selfreference they comprise the category of endophora. The effect of anaphoric references and noun phrase. Article information, pdf download for the effect of anaphoric references and noun phrase organizers on paragraph. Anaphora is an partial inversion of anadiplosis, which repeats words at the end. Anaphoric definition of anaphoric by the free dictionary. As a rhetorical device, or a technique that an author uses to persuade, anaphora is used for the purpose of generating a particular effect in your audience. Anaphoric where the pronoun occurs after the referent. Since anaphoric references refer back to a concept or word presented in a prior sentence, the concept referred to is old information and serves as a. The data were analyzed to see whether the awareness of referential relations affects reading comprehension, then a comparison was made between students performance in anaphora test.
It is the first attempt to develop a comprehensive 1 it should be clear that i am not a standard disinterested. It looked into what differentiated anaphora from deictic expressions and the different language mechanisms for anaphoric referencing. A referent is the object, idea, fact or event named by referred to by a referring expression typically a noun phrase or a pronoun. Anaphoric reference means that a word refers back to another word for its meaning, previously mentioned words. Anaphoric reference teachingenglish british council bbc. Charles dickens, in his novel a tale of two cities, made brilliant use of anaphora to convey a feeling of uncertainty about the past in arguably. We need syntax to describe the distribution of anaphoric expressions and their antecedents, and we need. By repeating a word or phrase, your readers or listeners start to anticipate the next line. The same goes to he which could be peter himself or someone else who was cheated.
What is the function of anaphoric and cataphoric reference. Anaphoric reference means that a word in a text refers back to other ideas in the text for its meaning. Jun 27, 2018 anaphoric reference occurs when a word or phrase refers to something mentioned earlier in the discourse. Logophoricity is a phenomenon of binding relation that may employ a morphologically different set of anaphoric forms, in the context where the referent is an entity whose speech, thoughts, or feelings are being reported. It thence provides the bedrock on which subsequent words are built. Most classifications that attempt to account for pronouns and demonstratives separate these expressions into referential and nonreferential categories. It offers a number of fascinating insights into the ways in which what might appear as random crosslinguistic variation in the domain of anaphora can be successfully understood in terms of the interaction among the syntactic. This entity may or may not be distant from the discourse, but the referent must reside in a clause external to the one in which the logophor resides. I love a bit of rhetoric, but people seem reluctant to use it. Anaphora has been used to powerful effect by some of the most influential public figures throughout history. Hi everyone, ive seen a little bit anaphoric cueing out there and am looking for more teachers or service providers or parents who have used it. Effect of anaphora anaphora appeals to the feelings, or pathos, of your audience. Journal of reading behavior x, 2 intersentence relations.
Reference and anaphoric relations studies in linguistics and philosophy. Endophoric reference is a more general term that includes both anaphoric and cataphoric reference. The cambridge grammar of the english language in its section p1506 on anaphoric uses of this and that with noun phrases as antecedents states. Anaphoric resolution and text comprehension for readers of german. When he arrived, john noticed that the door was open. The book addresses a wide range of issues in a number of specific. The role of the anaphoric referential relations in facilitating reading.
To understand the unit refered to by a cataphoric reference you would need to look ahead in the textspeech. Cataphoric reference teachingenglish british council bbc. So it refers to something inside the text, either earlier anaphoric or later cataphoric. The deliberate repetition of a word or phrase at the beginning of several successive verses, clauses, or paragraphs. Nov 21, 2010 the repetition in an anaphora helps to convey a sense of intensity, emphasis, force, insistence, seriousness, determination, etc. Eric ed243307 using tests of anaphoric reference in. The primacy effect says that things at the beginning are remembered.
Nov 30, 2001 reference and anaphoric relations studies in linguistics and philosophy heusinger, h. In this book, mary dalrymple provides a theory of the syntax of anaphoric binding, couched in the framework of lexicalfunctional grammar. The use of a linguistic unit, such as a pronoun, to refer ahead to another unit, for example, the use of him to refer to john in the sentence near him. Anaphoric definition is of or relating to anaphora. Reference and anaphoric relations studies in linguistics and philosophy heusinger, h. Anaphoric reference occurs when the writer refers back to someone or something that has been previously identified, to avoid repetition. Communication is achieved through texts or stretches of language. Linguists depend on the use of certain aspects in order to analyse, describe and explain a human language. Iraqi efl learners may not develop a full mastery of using anaphoric and cataphoric reference. In the example below, the writer exploits anaphoric reference for comic effect.
Anaphoric reference often makes use of the definite article the, because one of the. Because modern linguists are interested in communication and language use, they look into these stretches of language to see the coherence features otherwise. Anaphoric resolution and text comprehension for readers of. According to a theory of textual cohesion, anaphoric references and noun phrase organizers may serve as cohesive ties linking separate sentences into unified paragraphs. An example of cataphora in english is the following sentence. Here, it is a stylistic choice, to keep the reader in suspense as to who is being talked about. Cataphoric reference means that a word in a text refers to another later in the text and you need to look forward to understand. Pdf processing differences for anaphoric and cataphoric. Also called anaphoric reference or backwards anaphora. Jun 19, 2019 as you can see, whereas anaphora refers back, cataphora refers forward. The study of anaphora involves both syntax and semantics. Berkemeyer ohio state university introduction in the most basic sense, comprehension requires the integration of successive discourse elements within a text into a coherent conceptual representation. Cataphora is a type of anaphora, although the terms anaphora and anaphor are sometimes used in a stricter sense, denoting only cases where the order of the expressions is the reverse of that found in cataphora.
Once upon a time there was a prince who wanted to marry a. This study investigates the extent to which beginning to advanced students of english as a second language esl understand antecedentanaphora relationships in written discourse. Apart from the function of giving prominence to certain ideas, the use of anaphora in literature adds rhythm, thus making it more pleasurable to read, and easier to remember. Anaphora and language design is a major theoretical achievement within the domain of research of minimalist syntax. Anaphora and cataphora in italian emily fedele and elsi kaiser 1 introduction the question of what influences peoples interpretation and use of different referring expressions e. Five factors of comprehension of anaphoric reference were studied. Some desperate people tried scrambling over a barbedwire fence or a wall. Reference and anaphoric relations studies in linguistics.
1144 1028 1001 1495 1276 1402 102 25 28 610 203 607 1349 1120 1379 34 714 701 528 851 503 95 513 1156 483 116 1476 1445 201 1026 1290 199 1063 782 1288 385 1126 325 1443 1114